Dolly Wink Otona Collection New Brown Liquid Eyeliner Review,Swatches and Comparison(to the old black DW liner)

I just felt like I have to say this : 

This is my second time writing this because I accidentally deleted my completed post ! 

But since I am a dilligent person and I want to share my thoughts on this item, I have pain-stakingly written down everything again..

I love Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliners... but the pencil formula is just terrible and a waste of your money. You can get much better pencil eyeliners with more product for less price like the NYX Slide on eyeliner pencil. Enough with the pencil liners, now it's time to talk about liquid liners !!!

I have tried several other Western and Asian types of eyeliners with felt tips and brush tips. I personally love brush tips better because they give a fine line with awesome colour delivery.

Dolly Wink liquid eyeliners are often compared to the K-Pallete 24H Tattoo Liner, which I also have and used. The comparison I am going to talk about is on the black liners from the two brands. KP has a longer lasting power, but i don't like it since it's like a temporary tattoo and is hard to remove ; I have to tug my lids to remove it. Plus, the DW lasts long enough like 4-5 hours which is enough for me and the colour is a darker black.

Now .. Talking about the brown liner , I like the fact that DW has the same shape and brush tip that I very much love ..

Reasons to love the Otona Brown Liner:

- A medium brown that Looks more natural than the vivid black liner . If you like a natural look, it will suit you.

- Has an awesome brush tip that allows you to creat thin/ fine lines.

- Nicely Pigmented

- Lasts quite a long time 3-4 hourse without reapplying or smudging

- Doesnt burn/ sting your eyes when you apply it on the lower lashes or very closely to your lash line.

- Dries quickly

- Uber cute packaging !!! ( cute packaging+product is an awesome combo for a make up junkie!) 

Why it is not that awesome:

- Lasts 1 hour less than the old formulation ( for me )

- The brown might be too light for some people

- Hard to find . As far as I know, It is only available in Japan and maybe some online stores.

All in all I am satisfied with this eyeliner, It does it's job and it's a nice addition to my growing collection. I would use this instead of my Holy Grail DW Black one for a more natural daily look.

See you in the next post,

Cherry